Whenever we’re feeling saucy, we like to dig into a slice of local pizza. Indy’s pizza scene is bubbling with options — and we keep finding ways to top ourselves. If you’re on the quest for the perfect slice, we’ve pie-oneered a list of 15 places to grab pizza that are definitely worth the dough.
Local legends
Bazbeaux
, Multiple locations
With three locations and 37 years in business, Bazbeaux is an Indy icon. From traditional to exotic + premium toppings, plus multiple vegan options, you can truly build the pizza of your dreams here.
Jockamo’s Upper Crust Pizza
, Multiple locations
Jockamo’s is beloved for its huge menu of unique pizzas, like the Bollywood and the chicken broccoli alfredo. It even serves breakfast-style “hangover pizzas” all day Saturday + Sunday.
Pizza King
, Multiple locations
With its legendary feast pizzas, Pizza King has a taste recognizable to any Hoosier. It’s been around for over 60 years, and is known for its pizzas being “good to the very edge.”
Fancier fare
King Dough
, Holy Cross
Want a fancy date night, but also, pizza? King Dough takes pride in its upscale menu, from a grape + gorgonzola pizza to truffle fries. In fair weather months, it also has some of the best outdoor seating in the city.
Napolese
, Multiple locations
From six-time James Beard Foundation semifinalist Martha Hoover comes this elegant restaurant, which is all about artfully made pizza and stone hearth baking. Whether you hit the location in Meridian-Kessler or at The Fashion Mall at Keystone, the experience is sure to remain top-notch.
Byrne’s Grilled Pizza
, Meridian-Kessler
After getting its start as a humble food truck, Byrne’s has become a local staple, bolstered by not only its variety of unique pizzas but its special sauces like caper + olive or spicy beer cheese. The in-house Rhino Bar offers an impressive variety of wine and cocktails to round out your fancy meal.
Diavola
, Broad Ripple
Did someone say wine bar? This Broad Ripple restaurant slings truly gourmet pies, pastas, and wines from around the world — as well as the largest menu of Italian desserts that we’ve seen locally.
Cross-country crusts
Goodfellas
, Multiple locations
Night owls can confirm: Goodfellas knows what it’s doing. With locations smack dab in the middle of two of Indy’s biggest nightlife neighborhoods that are open until 3 a.m. on Fridays + Saturdays, there’s no better place to grab that much-needed late night slice of New York-style pie. Pro tip: the Mass Avenue location also has a cool speakeasy in the back with amazing cocktails.
Futuro
, Holy Cross
Known for its Detroit-style deep dish pizza, Futuro has made a name for itself with clever combos and huge pies. If you don’t love deep dish, thin crust and gluten-free crust options are also available.
Brozinni Pizzeria
, Multiple locations
Brozinni takes its identity as a New York-style joint seriously, with every pizza named after a location in the Big Apple. If you’re looking to dial up your NYC experience even further, add one of its amazing calzones or cannoli to your order.
Giorgio’s Pizza
, Mile Square
Big stuffed crust fan? You can choose any filling to stuff with your pizza with at this unassuming downtown restaurant. Led by an Italian-born chef, Giorgio’s also offers authentic Italian-style slices.
Think outside the pizza box
New Bethel Ordinary
, Wanamaker
The menu at NBO is anything but ordinary. Want to pair your pizza with maple sriracha wings? Or boom boom shrimp tacos? The options are almost endless.
Some Guys
, Glendale
For having such an unassuming name, this restaurant serves up some top-notch pies — plus an assortment of delicious pastas, subs, and salads for when you feel like shaking it up.
Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub
, Mile Square
Just two blocks from Monument Circle, this back-alley restaurant is the perfect stop before a game at Gainbridge Fieldhouse or Lucas Oil Stadium. It carries a wide selection of local microbrews on tap to go with your specialty pizza, wrap, or homemade soup.
Magoo’s California Pizza
, Eagledale
Magoo’s sets itself apart from its competitors by using 100% halal meats — and its kabob pizza is a menu standout. Plus, you can even order a burger or pizza naan here.
We know, this is just a piece of the pie. If your favorite pizza spot wasn’t mentioned, let us know so we can show it some love in the future.