Unique houses for sale in Fountain Square and Fletcher Place

Fletcher Place house_AB_3

The location is conveniently close to Amelia’s Bread + Chilly Water. | Photo by INDYtoday team

Table of Contents

A home built just 60 years after Indiana became a state went on the market in Fountain Square, and Hoosiers — it’s a showstopper.

Here’s what you need to know about this 1870s home, along with two others in the area.

A brief background

Although the Italianate Victorian structure was originally built as a single-family home (constructed by a father for his daughter), it was transformed into a boarding house at some point in its long history, which housed up to eight families.

What’s included:

  • Five beds
  • Two full baths
  • Four-car garage capacity
  • 3,292 sqft
  • Three parcels
  • An indoor stationary swim spa
  • A second, separate income duplex
  • A rooftop belvedere
  • Unfinished basement
  • Hot tub
Fletcher Place house_AB_2

The 360 view + spacious work area are to die for. | Photo by INDYtoday team

The details

Aside from all the features listed above, this house has a spacious + peaceful backyard with a brick path leading to the garage, which has enough space to be used as a workspace for artists, mechanics, and a number of other hobbyists.

Plus, we bet you can’t guess how many windows it has. Are you ready? The number you’re looking for is 84, according to the current owner. And you know that belvedere we mentioned? If you look through a telescope, you can see Lady Victory. Yes, the Lady Victory at Monument Circle.

The last nugget we’ll share is that the current owner carefully hand painted starburst-like details around all the windows + doors of the house, which give it an added layer of uniqueness.

Pro tip: An open house is scheduled on Sun., May 22 from 1-3 p.m. for those interested in touring the home.

Fletcher place house_AB_1

This is the second house, which is included in the three parcels. | Photo by INDYtoday team

Other homes for sale

📍 613 E. McCarty St.

3BR/3BA | $599,000 | Any spiral staircase fans out there? This 3,150-sqft single-family home has custom metal work, hardwood floors, two second-story balconies + a fireplace. In addition to that, the bathroom is newly renovated and the back porch has a hot tub.

📍 602 Fletcher Ave.

2 BR/2BA | $345,000 | At 1,939 sqft, this historic Victorian home has a two-car garage in the back of the property, a new roof + fresh exterior paint. Built in 1910, it has high ceilings, stained woodwork, and attic access. And just in time for summer, it features a covered porch.

More from INDYtoday