Our guide to some of the most supreme savory, sweet, and saucy sandwiches in the city

Which Indy wich is the one to rule them all? Here are just a few of the sandwiches that make our mouths water.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Nextdoor
  • Email

Turchettis is renowned for their selection of high-quality local meats and produce — which make for perfect sandwiches. | Photo by @turchettisdelicatessen

Get bready — it’s National Sandwich Month, and we’re going big (like foot-long big) with our list of some of the best sandos in the city.

Shapiro’s Delicatessen , 808 S. Meridian St. | No Indy sandwich roundup would be complete without Shapiro’s — which has been slinging legendary corned beef, pastrami, and much more since 1905. Thanks to the cafeteria-style setup, you also get your choice of delectable side dishes and desserts.

Turchetti’s Salumeria , 1110 Prospect St. | This one’s for the carnivores. The quality and taste of the Indiana-raised meat and hyper-local produce that make up Turchetti’s sandwiches is unmatched. The lunch special — a ‘wich and side for $11.99 — is hard to beat.

World Famous HotBoys , 1004 Virginia Ave. | Wanna really spice up your life? Check out these sandos filled with huge pieces of hot chicken (and we mean hot; it’s best to be conservative when selecting your spice level.) Pro tip: if you’re a fellow sauce fanatic, order an extra “money sauce.”

Every sandwich you order at HotBoys comes dripping with delicious housemade sauces. | Photo by @worldfamoushotboys

Chao Vietnamese Street Food , 7854 E. 96th St. | If you haven’t had a banh mi, are you really a sandwich fan? This joint in Fishers serves them up with your choice of protein. Make sure to grab a boba tea too.

Porter Books & Bread , 5719 Lawton Loop E. Dr. | Tucked into a nondescript corner of Lawrence is this cozy library cafe. Order a Vonnegut, Virgil, or any other sandwich named after your favorite author and tuck into a quiet nook to get some reading or work done.

Between the creative sandwiches and cozy vibes, Porter Books & Bread is the perfect place to hole up on a rainy (or sunny) day. Photo by @porterbooksandbread

Soupremacy , 7 E. Market St. | This cafe may be best known for its small batch soups, but its paninis shine just as bright. Try the Dirty Swede for a slightly sweet Meatless Monday shakeup.

Are we full of baloney? Send us your faves that we missed.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Nextdoor
  • Email
Shea lives in Indianapolis, IN. She previously worked as a producer for a creative marketing agency. In her spare time, you can find her doing anything and everything active, belting musical theatre songs in the car next to you, or hunting down the perfect cup of chai.
More from INDYtoday