The humble history of the pork tenderloin

Do you know the origin story of the pork tenderloin? Here’s how, when, and where every Hoosier’s favorite sandwich was created.

INDYtoday: INDY_Nick's Kitchen pork tenderloin history_FEB26

Pictured are the employees of Nick’s Kitchen circa 1920 — about 15-20 years after the pork tenderloin was born.

We’ve all had one (or 300) — but how many of us can recite the history of the pork tenderloin? The next time you reach for Indiana’s unofficial state sandwich, you can spout off these fun facts.

Indiana foodie historians believe the pork tenderloin as we know it was first served in the early 1900s by Nick Freienstein, the son of German immigrants. It seems likely that Freienstein riffed off of the Viennese wiener schnitzel — no, not the national hot dog chain.

A traditional wiener schnitzel is a thin, breaded, and fried cut of veal. Freienstein used the widely-available pork instead, slapped it between two buns, added pickles, and voila — the pork tenderloin was born.

INDY_pork tenderloin sandwich_Four Day Ray_JUNE2023

You can get this Indiana classic for $14.50 at Four Day Ray in Fishers and Yorktown.

Photo by Four Day Ray via Hamilton County Tourism

Freienstein sold his sandwiches from a cart at Huntington County’s courthouse square for several years, until he saved up enough money to open Nick’s Kitchen in 1908. Located at 506 North Jefferson St. in Huntington, the restaurant has changed hands many times over the years but is still in business today, serving the most authentic version of the sandwich we all know and love.

Have you tried Nick’s Kitchen’s pork tenderloin, or is there another local version you’re loyal to? Don’t hog your favorite — share it with us for a chance to be featured in an upcoming newsletter.

More from INDYtoday
There’s no place like a Lustron home. Here’s a quick history lesson on the iconic + rare midcentury houses, plus where you can peep some for yourself around Indy.
Put your money where your community is and help us create a guide to small businesses by submitting your favorite local spots and sharing this page with a friend.
Avril Lavigne? Check. Keith Urban? Check. It’s not a bad idea to triple-check this list and get your concert tickets before they sell out.
Dining in Indy is always a fresh experience with new restaurants popping up all the time — and more on the way.
Ready for your lunch break? Check out these lunches from sandwiches to diverse eats.
Padel is popping up around the Circle City, and these spots make it easy to try out the sport.
Want to get hygge — aka cozy and warm? Here’s how you can embrace the Danish and Norwegian principle to make weathering the Indianapolis winter a little easier.
Whether you’re a lifelong matcha lover or just now getting into the drink thanks to social media trends, here’s where you can find just a few green dreams around Indy.
Here’s how to prep your garden for the spring.
Spooky season is back for one day only on Friday the 13th — spend it well with these 13 fun ideas.