Whenever we’re feeling saucy, we like to dig into a slice of local pizza. Indy’s pizza scene is bubbling with options — and we keep finding ways to top ourselves. If you’re on the quest for the perfect slice, we’ve pie-oneered a list of 15 places to grab pizza that are definitely worth the dough.
Local legends
Bazbeaux, Multiple locations
With three locations and 37 years in business, Bazbeaux is an Indy icon. From traditional to exotic + premium toppings, plus multiple vegan options, you can truly build the pizza of your dreams here.
Jockamo’s Upper Crust Pizza, Multiple locations
Jockamo’s is beloved for its huge menu of unique pizzas, like the Bollywood and the chicken broccoli alfredo. It even serves breakfast-style “hangover pizzas” all day Saturday + Sunday.
Pizza King, Multiple locations
With its legendary feast pizzas, Pizza King has a taste recognizable to any Hoosier. It’s been around for over 60 years, and is known for its pizzas being “good to the very edge.”
We never thought we’d be ordering truffle fries to go alongside our pizza — thanks to King Dough for changing the game.
Photo by @kingdoughindy
Fancier fare
King Dough, Holy Cross
Want a fancy date night, but also, pizza? King Dough takes pride in its upscale menu, from a grape + gorgonzola pizza to truffle fries. In fair weather months, it also has some of the best outdoor seating in the city.
Napolese, Multiple locations
From six-time James Beard Foundation semifinalist Martha Hoover comes this elegant restaurant, which is all about artfully made pizza and stone hearth baking. Whether you hit the location in Meridian-Kessler or at The Fashion Mall at Keystone, the experience is sure to remain top-notch.
Byrne’s Grilled Pizza, Meridian-Kessler
After getting its start as a humble food truck, Byrne’s has become a local staple, bolstered by not only its variety of unique pizzas but its special sauces like caper + olive or spicy beer cheese. The in-house Rhino Bar offers an impressive variety of wine and cocktails to round out your fancy meal.
Diavola, Broad Ripple
Did someone say wine bar? This Broad Ripple restaurant slings truly gourmet pies, pastas, and wines from around the world — as well as the largest menu of Italian desserts that we’ve seen locally.
Futuro’s deep dish pizzas are so deep, you’re likely to fill up after just two slices.
Photo by @futuroindy
Cross-country crusts
Goodfellas, Multiple locations
Night owls can confirm: Goodfellas knows what it’s doing. With locations smack dab in the middle of two of Indy’s biggest nightlife neighborhoods that are open until 3 a.m. on Fridays + Saturdays, there’s no better place to grab that much-needed late night slice of New York-style pie. Pro tip: the Mass Avenue location also has a cool speakeasy in the back with amazing cocktails.
Futuro, Holy Cross
Known for its Detroit-style deep dish pizza, Futuro has made a name for itself with clever combos and huge pies. If you don’t love deep dish, thin crust and gluten-free crust options are also available.
Brozinni Pizzeria, Multiple locations
Brozinni takes its identity as a New York-style joint seriously, with every pizza named after a location in the Big Apple. If you’re looking to dial up your NYC experience even further, add one of its amazing calzones or cannoli to your order.
Giorgio’s Pizza, Mile Square
Big stuffed crust fan? You can choose any filling to stuff with your pizza with at this unassuming downtown restaurant. Led by an Italian-born chef, Giorgio’s also offers authentic Italian-style slices.
Enjoy a pizza fresh out of the oven at New Bethel Ordinary — or order take and bake to make it yourself at home.
Photo by @nbopizza
Think outside the pizza box
New Bethel Ordinary, Wanamaker
The menu at NBO is anything but ordinary. Want to pair your pizza with maple sriracha wings? Or boom boom shrimp tacos? The options are almost endless.
Some Guys, Glendale
For having such an unassuming name, this restaurant serves up some top-notch pies — plus an assortment of delicious pastas, subs, and salads for when you feel like shaking it up.
Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub, Mile Square
Just two blocks from Monument Circle, this back-alley restaurant is the perfect stop before a game at Gainbridge Fieldhouse or Lucas Oil Stadium. It carries a wide selection of local microbrews on tap to go with your specialty pizza, wrap, or homemade soup.
Magoo’s California Pizza, Eagledale
Magoo’s sets itself apart from its competitors by using 100% halal meats — and its kabob pizza is a menu standout. Plus, you can even order a burger or pizza naan here.
We know, this is just a piece of the pie. If your favorite pizza spot wasn’t mentioned, let us know so we can show it some love in the future.
