When it comes to Indy’s shopping scene, we love a good treasure hunt — and a good bargain. Our city is home to several fabulous flea markets, vibrant vintage shops, and resale gems. So get in, we’re going shopping.
Flea markets
Emporium Flea Markets, various locations
This local institution has four locations across central Indiana, each hosting 200+ vendors. Our favorite, Emporium 40, is open seven days a week for all your thrifting needs.
Irvington Flea Market, Irvington
Find this longtime market open Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays in the Irvington Shopping Plaza. The wide selection of items available for sale truly reflects the 27 years of business under its belt.
Trader Buck’s Flea Market, Speedway
Eclectic doesn’t even begin to cover this flea market’s offerings — head their way to see for yourself. Bonus: The group also operates the Peddler’s Mall on the east side, if that’s closer to home.
Strawtown Flea Market, Strawtown
Any antique lover should make the pilgrimage up to Strawtown to check out this historic market. Open at daylight every Thursday, it features both outdoor and indoor sellers + public auctions in the evening.
If you’re looking for a sweatshirt your cool uncle might have rocked at the local basketball court in the 90s, you’ll find it at Naptown Thrift.
Photo by @naptownthrift
Vintage shops
Broad Ripple Vintage, Broad Ripple
This cozy, family-owned shop feels like a tie-dyed trip through the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame. It carries unique men’s and women’s finds from the 40s to the 80s.
Zodiac Vintage, Fountain Square
Got the 90s fever? Hit up Zodiac Vintage for the campy tees of your dreams, plus luxury finds, everyday treasures, and Levis galore.
Naptown Thrift, North Kessler Manor
If you’re wondering where all the cool kids shop, this is it. Find funky athleisure and streetwear within the concrete-floored, nostalgia-packed store or online.
Midland Arts & Antique Market, Holy Cross
You’ve probably driven past this enormous building right off I-65 thousands of times, and its interior is no less impressive. You’ll find high quality antique furniture, well-preserved vintage clothing, and endless collectibles from 150+ vendors inside.
Nuova Vita recently moved into its new space in The Stutz.
Photo by @nuova.vita.vintage
Nuova Vita Vintage, The Stutz
Italian for “new life,” Nuova Vita Vintage was launched by Macey Schumacher in 2020. Its thoughtfully curated collection embodies quiet luxury, with everything from clothing to jewelry to candles.
Market Vintage, Irvington
Located on the first floor of the former Masonic Lodge 666, this shop embodies + embraces its quirky neighborhood, frequently hosting events that spotlight other small local businesses. The owner also co-owns Satellite Vintage, another unique spot in Broad Ripple that caters to “disco space cowboys.”
Lux & Ivy, Canterbury
Discover 40 local + independent brands as well as a tightly curated selection of vintage clothing at this shop. Since its inception in 2012, it’s championed slow fashion, hosting events to educate the public on the benefits of shopping sustainably.
Popular brands often found at The Toggery include Anthropologie, Madewell, and Lululemon.
Photo by @thetoggeryresale
Resale and consignment shops
The Toggery, Broad Ripple
Whether you’re looking for new or designer, to buy or to sell, The Toggery has everything you need. Pro tip: Its Instagram account also creates fun #OOTD posts to give you a peek at items for sale + generate inspiration for dressing with what you already own.
Consigned by Design, Fishers
In the market for fine furniture and home decor without the steep price tag? Check out this store, which offers a robust online shopping experience in addition to its two sophisticated storefronts. It even carries a small assortment of designer fashion accessories.
Mission 27 Resale, various locations
Run by the Society of St. Vincent de Paul, this thrift store provides a variety of quality items at unbelievably low prices — and all for a good cause. Pro tip: Their inventory moves quickly, so if you see something you love, don’t wait.
Newman & Co. Consignment, Broad Ripple
This shop specializes in men’s clothing and accessories, ranging from high-end designer pieces to casual wear. It added a furniture section in 2022, meaning that Pottery Barn armchair you’ve been eyeing just got more affordable.
