Historic home guidelines in Indianapolis, IN

Learn what makes a home historic and which neighborhoods have been around the longest.

A Historic Fletcher Place sign with apartment building in background

Fletcher Place gets its name from one of its first residents, Calvin Fletcher.

Photo by INDYtoday team

Table of Contents

With more than 250 registered historic buildings and nine National Historic Landmarks — most of which were built during the 19th century — there’s no shortage of sites for the history buffs out there.

But what about when it comes to residential houses? Whether you’re looking to buy in a historic neighborhood or you’re curious if your old bungalow qualifies, keep reading.

What makes a home historic?

Despite the number of centuries-old buildings in Indy, a home only needs to be more than 50 years old to be considered “historic,” so anything built before 1973 could qualify. However, there are a few catches if you want your home to be on the National Register.

Houses must:

  • Be associated with a person or event of historical significance
  • Have architectural or engineering integrity or have high artistic value
  • Be built 50 or more years ago with no major renovations

What makes a district historic?

Historic districts should have high marks in the following areas:

  • Consist of structures in the same locations they were originally built
  • Maintain the proper aesthetic based on style and details
  • Have defined boundaries
  • Contain original physical elements and materials
  • Show effort in structural quality
  • Be associated with people, groups, or events of historic impact

There are 12 historic districts in Indianapolis: Wholesale District, Fountain Square, Woodruff Place, Lockefield Gardens, The Old Northside, St. Joseph, Lockerbie Square, Chatham Arch and Massachusetts Avenue, Monument Circle, Herron-Morton Place, Fletcher Place, and Irvington.

How can my home get historic recognition?

We have a few tips for finding out if your home is historic, including:

Once you’ve gathered all of your information, you can start the registration process.

Have more questions? We recommend checking out Indiana Landmarks and Indiana DNR for more info.

More from INDYtoday
Want to get hygge — aka cozy and warm? Here’s how you can embrace the Danish and Norwegian principle to make weathering the Indianapolis winter a little easier.
Whether you’re a lifelong matcha lover or just now getting into the drink thanks to social media trends, here’s where you can find just a few green dreams around Indy.
Here’s how to prep your garden for the spring.
Spooky season is back for one day only on Friday the 13th — spend it well with these 13 fun ideas.
Let the good times roll, Indy. Here’s how you can celebrate Mardi Gras right here in the Circle City, 820 miles away from the French Quarter.
Spending Valentine’s Day at home? Here’s how you can still have a special night without breaking the bank, hiring a sitter, or even leaving your couch.
From clowning to coding, find a camp that speaks to your kid’s unique interests.
Avril Lavigne? Check. Keith Urban? Check. It’s not a bad idea to triple-check this list and get your concert tickets before they sell out.
Feel like you’re driving on an obstacle course around Indy? Pothole season is officially here, so we’re sharing how you can help be part of the solution.
Get started on filing your tax return with these free resources.