Support Us Button Widget

One near-east side diner’s future in Indianapolis, IN

The Sanitary Diner has been vacant for years. What’s next for the retro haven?

Exterior shot of Sanitary Diner

You can find the Sanitary Diner at 99 Cruse St.

Photo by INDYtoday team

The possibilities are endless for this vacant diner tucked just behind Futuro on the near east side.

When we posted about this hidden gem back in January, you all seemed very interested in learning about its current status. Well, it looks like that’s still being decided.

It appears it’s currently occupied by 1820 Ventures LLC, who recently asked its Instagram followers what should be done with the space, saying “it really wants to be the epicenter of Elevator Hill.”

If you ask us, we think it should remain a diner + serve all the Hoosier classics — tenderloins, sweet corn, and sugar cream pie. What would you like to see?

We know what you’re thinking: what’s up with the name? The decision to call it “The Sanitary Diner” was apparently meant to advertise its cleanliness back in the 1930s, when tuberculosis was still prevalent.

More from INDYtoday
Plenty of Indianapolis business + restaurants, plus the city itself, landed in high spots on “best of” lists in 2024.
There are 38 Indy James Beard Award winners and semifinalists from years past — let’s get to know them a little bit ahead of the 2024 awards.
From Aries to Pisces, find the bookstore that will speak to your sign.
To help make your entire process at the Indianapolis International Airport as smooth as possible, we’ve created a guide that covers everything from gates and parking to details on the airport’s nonstop flights.
Escape the cold and snow in Indianapolis by taking one of these affordable flights to a new city.
If one of your new year goals is to shop + support locally owned and operated businesses, bookmark these ins and outs to follow throughout the year.
Devour Winterfest is back and we’re helping you plan ahead for your dinner dates.
Pacers Sports & Entertainment said “the center and amenities will be designed to address the specific needs and female athletes competing at the highest level, including performance and conditioning, recovery and rehabilitation, mental health and wellness, and lifestyle support.”
Check out these restaurants, cafes, and diners serving all the omelets, mimosas, and waffles you need to start your day on the right foot.
Dining in Indy is always a fresh experience with new restaurants popping up all the time — and more on the way.