Support Us Button Widget

Where to shop secondhand in Indianapolis, IN

Table of Contents

About 10.5 million tons of clothing are sent to landfills every year, so today (Thurs., Aug. 25) we’re celebrating National Secondhand Wardrobe Day by visiting one of these local vintage + consignment shops.

Broad Ripple/SoBro

The Toggery, 1810 Broad Ripple Ave., Ste. 4

This men’s and women’s consignment store has been around since 1986 + focuses on providing designer looks for up to 70% off the retail price.

Newman & Co., 720 E. 65th St.

This shop is known as Indy’s only men’s ware consignment store.

279262591_550836516466613_3327587760294092765_n

Newman & Co. also carries furniture and home goods. | Photo by @newmanco.shop

Downtown

Nuova Vita Vintage, 907 N. Pennsylvania St.

Just in time for that transition to fall fashion, Nuova Vita Vintage released 100+ hand-selected fall collection pieces.

Zodiac Vintage, 1060 Virginia Ave.

You may also recognize this Fountain Square staple from the many pop-up markets Indy has had over the past year.

North side

Thrifty Threads, 1501 W. 86th St.

This thrift store + donation center is owned and operated by The Julian Center — the state’s largest organization supporting victims of domestic violence, sexual assault, and other life crises.

Hot House Market, 8701 Keystone Crossing

This locally-owned shop in the Fashion Mall has a wide range of hand-picked vintage pieces, as well as current trends. Fun Fact: Nicole briefly worked at this shop before becoming your City Editor.

South side

Clothes Rack, 3121 W. Thompson Rd.

We couldn’t find a website or active social media page for this shop (does this qualify it as a hidden gem?) but online reviews claim this shop has it all — from reasonable prices to great quality and selections.

Selective Seconds, 1000 N. State Rd. 135, Greenwood

Shopping at a thrift or consignment store can be overwhelming in person, so this shop offers online shopping and live shopping on Facebook.

More from INDYtoday
We’re grateful for our favorite dine-in and carry-out options for Thanksgiving dinner this year, plus local ingredients.
Find out how to dispose of old pumpkins + leaves ahead of the holidays.
Take a peek inside historic homes along Meridian Street with massive square footage, unique architectural features, and intriguing stories + past owners.
If you’re inspired to run, walk, or trot as the weather starts cooling down, check out these seasonal struts happening around Indy.
Get your sweat on with something a little less common than your standard HIIT or yoga class.
From the Colts to the Pacers, we’re sharing all details of Indianapolis sports teams.
At INDYtoday we provide all the ins and outs of the Circle City — but our sister cities under the 6AM umbrella reach far beyond the 317. Here’s the expert local advice you need to visit a few of our friends.
INDYtoday readers shared which local restaurants + meals they miss the most — and we think you’ll agree.
Looking for a weird way to spend your Halloween day? Here are some suggestions — and most of them are free.
Just in time for Taylor Swift at Lucas Oil, the Cultural Trail cut the ribbon on its South Street expansion. Next is the groundbreaking for the Henry Street bridge project for connectivitiy.