The beginner’s guide to composting in Indianapolis

Have questions like “What is composting?” and “How do I compost in an apartment?” Here’s everything you need to know to start your composting journey.

A heap of tomatoes and vegetation in a dark brown wooden bin outside.

One person’s organic trash is another’s compost treasure. | Photo by Eva Bronzini via Pexels

Table of Contents

Ready to begin composting? We’ve got the dirt on how to get started, plus the best compost bin for your needs.

What is composting?

Composting is the process of decomposing organic matter — like leaves, food scraps, and yard trimmings. You reap what you sow: The result is a dark, nutrient-heavy material, like soil, that you can use to enrich your lawn or garden.

How do you get started?

Find a dry and shady spot in your backyard to build your compost pile. Be patient — composting can take several months.

If you don’t want a pile of decomposing waste in your backyard, try a compost bin. Here’s some options we’ve bin eyeing:

  • For beginners | Try it out before you commit. This bin is easy to clean and is perfect for collecting scraps on your counter.
  • For style icons | Composting, but make it cute. Just don’t mistake this odor-free bin for your cookie jar.
  • For the serious gardener | This 43-gallon container rotates — no more mixing compost by hand — and has two chambers so you can add fresh waste while the older batch finishes up.
  • For the landscaper | If you plan to compost mostly yard waste, this open-top bin is a good alternative to a pile.

Pro tip: Green With Indy offers troubleshooting tips if your compost isn’t cooperating.

Can you compost without a backyard?

If you’re an apartment dweller or simply don’t have the backyard space, you might want to give worm composting a try. Simply purchase a special bin and some worms, and let your squirmy new pets feast on your scraps.

✅ What can you compost?

Compost should be a blend of waste containing nitrogen (green waste) and carbon (brown waste) like:

  • Green: fruits, vegetables, bread, coffee grounds, grass clippings, tea, and hair
  • Brown: dryer lint, egg shells, nut shells, sawdust, hay, leaves, shredded paper, and cardboard

While all of these materials will decay eventually, mixing green and brown waste together will likely speed up the process — especially if you experiment and find the right carbon to nitrogen ratio.

❌ What can’t you compost?

Not everything decomposes well. Be sure to avoid composting stuff like:

  • Inorganic materials: metal, plastic, produce stickers, treated wood
  • Animal products: dairy, meat, bones, pet feces

How do you use compost?

Composting is good for the soul… and the soil. Make it into mulch, mix it into your flower and vegetable beds, or spread it over your lawn.

No garden? No problem. Mix some of that compost into your potting soil to give indoor plants a boost. If your home has a growing need for more green life, find your next leafy friend at one of these local houseplant shops.

You can also use compost to make a difference if you don’t plan on using it to feed your yard or garden. Indianapolis has buckets of services that will pick up compost, including:

The Broad Ripple Farmers Market also features a composting table each Saturday. A representative from Indy Go Green will help to reduce landfill waste and make the most out of wanted scraps.

More from INDYtoday
Put your money where your community is and help us create a guide to small businesses by submitting your favorite local spots and sharing this page with a friend.
Beleaf it or not, an estimated 30 million Americans drink tea every day. Here are some places you can have a beau-tea-ful afternoon tea experience — or just grab a simple cup.
Whether you’re a casual cardinal custodian or a lifelong lark lover, here’s where you can start birding, learn more about local species, and catch a glimpse of them crossing the skies.
In honor of the MICHELIN Guide expanding into the Great Lakes region of the U.S. with Indianapolis included, here are a few restaurants we think deserve the prestigious honor.
Avril Lavigne? Check. Keith Urban? Check. It’s not a bad idea to triple-check this list and get your concert tickets before they sell out.
Love your city? Get engaged by joining a board or commission related to a topic you’re passionate about or have experience in.
With the Masters Tournament right around the corner, we took a swing at narrowing down what local food picks we would bring to the Masters Champions Dinner table.
Mother Earth is defrosting, and she’s sprouting dozens of edible plants + flowers that you can find in your own backyard. Go on the hunt with our foraging guide.
Pack your reusable shopping bags — we’ve rounded up eight farmers markets around Indianapolis with everything from fresh produce to gorgeous flowers and beyond.
Here are just a few of the ways local businesses trolled Hoosiers with silly jokes, fake product launches, and more on April Fools’ Day.