Support Us Button Widget

So close, but so far: Chain restaurants readers wish were in Indy

Sure, you could road trip to your favorite chain restaurants — but wouldn’t it be better if they were right down the road?

A photo of two burgers and fry platters from In-N-Out Burger.

We’ll toast a boat of Animal Style fries to these reader recs.

Photo by INDYtoday

Ever feel like your favorite chain restaurants open new locations everywhere but Indianapolis? We asked readers what chains they hope will join the Circle City dining scene. You’re welcome, restaurant executives.

In-N-Out Burger | Nearest location: Rockwall, TX (~877 miles)
Numerous readers wrote in sharing their love for this West Coast-based burger joint. For now, those craving a Double-Double prepared Animal Style are in for a hefty road trip — or a nonstop flight to Dallas.

A photo of a burger, fries, and drink from Whataburger with the restaurant in the background.

What would be the first thing you’d order if Whataburger came to town?

Photo by CLTtoday

Whataburger | Nearest location: Hermitage, TN (~287 miles)
Burgers are on the brain, because this fast food chain was also a top request; to quote reader Lisa M., “please!!!”

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom | Nearest location: Lexington, KY (~175 miles)
Our readers still crave this chain’s deep-dish style pies. The last Indiana location closed earlier this year.

While specific restaurants varied, other cuisines readers hope to see in Naptown included Mexican, barbecue, and salad-forward spots.

Bonus: These restaurants may not be opening in Indianapolis, but we know which ones are.

More from INDYtoday
The 16th annual edition of Small Business Saturday falls on November 29 — the perfect time to help you add a local sparkle into your holiday shopping.
Ready to live your Nancy Kerrigan or Michelle Kwan fantasy? Here are some local ice skating rinks where you can polish your skills (or barely scoot along — we get it).
Explore a variety of enchanting wedding venues around Indianapolis with our comprehensive guide. From rustic historic buildings to elegant ballrooms, we make it easy for you to discover the perfect location for your dream wedding.
This year, igloo pop-ups at local bars and restaurants are all the (icy-hot) rage. Here are a few you can try for yourself.
Saunas are no longer just about sweating it out — they’re becoming Indy’s newest way to unwind, socialize, and network.
Avril Lavigne? Check. Keith Urban? Check. It’s not a bad idea to triple-check this list and get your concert tickets before they sell out.
“Wicked: For Good” hits theaters on Friday, Nov. 21. Here’s how we’d spend one short day in the Circle City just like Elphaba and Glinda.
Warm your hands and heart with these soulful, hearty soups around the Circle City that are perfect served on a cold winter day.
If you feel inspired to run, walk, or trot as the weather starts cooling down, check out these seasonal struts happening around Indy.
The Clowns are returning to Indy after more than 35 years. Here’s how they originally got to the Circle City, plus some fun trivia facts to impress your friends.