Would You Rather: Indy edition

Are you a Hoosier in search of a conversation starter? Look no further, because we’ve compiled a list of locally-inspired questions that could ignite quite a debate at the watercooler.

Downtown street at night

No, your answer can’t be “both.”

Everyone’s familiar with the game, “Would You Rather,” but we’re putting a local spin on the icebreaker.

Disclaimer: INDYtoday is not responsible for any heated debates that may result from this game.

Would you rather...

  • Only eat St. Elmo’s shrimp cocktail or Long’s glazed yeast donuts?
  • Have unlimited access to Fountain Square’s Rooftop Garden or Petite Chou’s patio?
  • Go on a shopping spree at the Keystone Fashion Mall or at one of Six Ways Markets’ outdoor vendor markets?
  • End the construction in Broad Ripple or on 38th Street?
  • Never have to wait for a table at Bodhi or The Eagle?
  • Visit Indy 150 years into the past or 150 years into the future?
  • Sing karaoke at Metro or play trivia at Metazoa Brewing Co.?
  • Bring back The Sinking Ship or Bourbon Street?

Let us know what you’re picking and don’t forget to leave suggestions for the next round of “Would You Rather.”

More from INDYtoday
Like your Diet Coke jazzed up with creamers, syrups, and fruit purees? Here’s where you can find trendy dirty sodas around Indianapolis (without waiting in the line at Swig.)
Keep local love growing this spring with native plants that will support pollinators, save water, and make your yard or garden look beautiful.
In honor of Women’s History Month, we’re spotlighting women in Indianapolis making history through their work happening right now.
Chase the rainbow at these St. Patrick’s Day events around the Circle City.
Did you know Indianapolis used to have its own gossip newspaper, ala Lady Whistledown from “Bridgerton?” Here’s a brief history of “The Locomotive.”
Dining in Indy is always a fresh experience with new restaurants popping up all the time — and more on the way.
Bookmark this guide for a curated list of events taking place each month that we’re most looking forward to.
We stumbled upon records of a long-lost bookstore and publishing company with the name of W.K. Stewart that was owned by a relative of Kurt Vonnegut. Here’s everything we know — and what we’re still trying to find out.
Enjoy dinner and a show when you visit one of these local hibachi restaurants.
Help conserve water and lower the cost of your bills by building an eco-friendly rainwater collection system in your backyard.