Would You Rather: Indy edition

Are you a Hoosier in search of a conversation starter? Look no further, because we’ve compiled a list of locally-inspired questions that could ignite quite a debate at the watercooler.

Downtown street at night

No, your answer can’t be “both.”

Everyone’s familiar with the game, “Would You Rather,” but we’re putting a local spin on the icebreaker.

Disclaimer: INDYtoday is not responsible for any heated debates that may result from this game.

Would you rather...

  • Only eat St. Elmo’s shrimp cocktail or Long’s glazed yeast donuts?
  • Have unlimited access to Fountain Square’s Rooftop Garden or Petite Chou’s patio?
  • Go on a shopping spree at the Keystone Fashion Mall or at one of Six Ways Markets’ outdoor vendor markets?
  • End the construction in Broad Ripple or on 38th Street?
  • Never have to wait for a table at Bodhi or The Eagle?
  • Visit Indy 150 years into the past or 150 years into the future?
  • Sing karaoke at Metro or play trivia at Metazoa Brewing Co.?
  • Bring back The Sinking Ship or Bourbon Street?

Let us know what you’re picking and don’t forget to leave suggestions for the next round of “Would You Rather.”

More from INDYtoday
We compiled all of the feedback from our Giving Campaign to learn what readers love most and want to see more of in our newsletters. Here’s a peek at what they said.
In addition to wild geese that fly with the moon on their wings, these are a few of my favorite things — that are hyperspecific to Indianapolis.
What’s there to do in Indianapolis when you’re an introvert? We’ve cooked up a few ways you can get out on the town while staying in your comfort zone.
Dining in Indy is always a fresh experience with new restaurants popping up all the time — and more on the way.
Get your sweat on with something a little less common than your standard HIIT or yoga class.
Whether you’re looking to save money, improve your physical fitness, or something else, find the resources you need to stick to your New Year’s resolutions in 2026.
At these 10 miniature art galleries in the Indy area, you can take a piece of art or leave one for your neighbors to love.
Explore the options for giving your old tree new life, from dropping it off to be turned into mulch to creating a wildlife haven in your yard.
Fellow stargazers, consult our chart for a few spots around Indy to escape the light pollution of the city and look to the sky.
Bookmark this guide for a curated list of events taking place each month that we’re most looking forward to.