Pop quiz, Indianapolis. What’s better than shopping local? For 100 points: Shopping local from the comfort of your own home, of course. Not only is it one of the best ways to support the local economy, but locally-crafted gifts tend to wow during the holidays (a big win in our book).
To kickstart your holiday shopping, we’ve rounded up 19 products we love from local Etsy shops — some of which hold the coveted Star Seller badge that’s given to sellers who consistently earn 5-star reviews, ship orders on time, and provide great customer service, aka less holiday stress for you.
Psst — Some of these items may sell out quickly due to limited quantities. Click on the link to the Etsy seller’s page to find something similar.
🎁 Under $25
Personalized return address stamp ($24.99+) | Spice up your holiday cards, invitations, or any letter with this rustic return address stamp. | Paper Peach Shop — Star Seller ⭐️
Lavender wide bandana headband ($14) | A brightly colored bandana headband. | Specifically Random — Star Seller ⭐️
Christmas ice cream sundae kit ($12.50) | Pair with a can of whipped cream, a jar of maraschino cherries, their favorite ice cream and bam — best gift ever. | Outside the Box Papers — Star Seller ⭐️
Kids monogrammed bucket hat ($13.99+) | These children’s embroidered bucket hats fit sizes 2-4T + come in several different colors. | Nyla Kelley Designs — Star Seller ⭐️
“Tribe” friendship bracelet ($15+) | A minimalist bracelet with a meaningful message.| Verse Three
Shampoo and conditioner bar set ($24.95) | Select your own fragrance + help the environment with these handmade shampoo and conditioner bars — no plastic necessary. | Get Lathered
Men’s Celtic bracelet ($24.99) | This unique bracelet is handmade, offers two charm selections, and is customizable by wrist size. | Clever Bird Boutique
🎁 $25-$50
The original macrame fruit hammock ($33) | Stylish, useful, and great for small spaces. | MacraYAY Macrame — Star Seller ⭐️
Dainty minimalist ring stack ($44+) | This simple but stylish ring stack adds a classic touch to any outfit. | Sloane Jewelry Design — Star Seller ⭐️
Flower bookmark ($32) | A hand-crafted bookmark that wraps around your book with flat black elastic. | Love Maude — Star Seller ⭐️
“Strawberry Thief” business card holder ($25+) | Never lose track of your business cards again with this decorative holder designed to keep your cards in one place. | Decorative Design WKS — Star Seller ⭐️
Solid wood watch box ($39.99+) | For the person with multiple watches — an espresso colored watch box with a glass display top. | Case Elegance — Star Seller ⭐️
Sterling silver mushroom ring ($40.65+) | This mushroom ring is made from .925 Sterling Silver and is perfect for the nature lover in your life. | Hannah Catherines — Star Seller ⭐️
🎁 $50-$100+
Alpaca wool blanket ($99) | A handmade, soft blanket to keep warm in all winter long. | Latitude Zero EC — Star Seller ⭐️
Woodland nursery decor ($319.99+) | Transform a nursery or playroom completely with this stick-on scene kids will love. | Sono Luna — Star Seller ⭐️
Knife making kit ($144.99) | DIY a knife with this deluxe kit. | Indy Hammered Knives — Star Seller ⭐️
Leather toiletry travel bag ($62) | Travel in style with this leather toiletry bag that comes in two different colors. | The Path Less Traveled — Star Seller ⭐️
Custom paw print coffee mug ($70+) | Surprise them with a coffee mug featuring their pet’s actual paw print. | Fatty Frog Pots
String art “Home Sweet Home” sign ($72+) | A unique, artistic sign to warm up a space. | The Honaker Home Maker
